Jump to Navigation
Home

Main menu

  • Home
  • News
  • Markets Map
  • Sentiments
  • Topics
  • Data
  • Comments
  • Images
  • Blog
  • About

Secondary menu

  • Latest News
  • Top Rated
  • Most Popular
  • Archive
  • Discussions
  • China's pension insurance covers 486m people
  • Top trading strategies for the coming week
  • The Brady Bunch Market
  • Amazing timelapse at Sydney light show
  • Will Obama be the prez with the best stk mkt record?
  • Pfizer Will Reward Shareholders With Zoetis Spin-Off
  • Markets may see some correction in short term: SMC
  • UK zoo worker dies after tiger mauling
  • ‘I don’t think the matter is going to go away’: Deputy...
  • Sudipta cash trail may lead to Singapore, Bangkok

    Do Political Science Departments Ignore Conservatism?

    Mon, 07/13/2009 - 11:26 EDT - Mathew Yglesias
    • Comments
    • Harvard
    • Peter Berkowitz
    • uncat
    • Wall Street Journal

    Peter Berkowitz offers some old whine in a slightly new bottle:
    The political science departments at elite private universities such as Harvard and Yale, at leading small liberal arts colleges like Swarthmore and Williams, and at distinguished large public universities like the University of Maryland and the University of California, Berkeley, offer undergraduates a variety of courses on a range of topics. But one topic the undergraduates at these institutions — and at the vast majority of other universities and colleges — are unlikely to find covered is conservatism. [...]
    But most students will hear next to nothing about the conservative tradition in American politics that stretches from John Adams to Theodore Roosevelt to William F. Buckley Jr. to Milton Friedman to Ronald Reagan. This tradition emphasizes moral and intellectual excellence, worries that democratic practices and egalitarian norms will threaten individual liberty, attends to the claims of religion and the role it can play in educating citizens for liberty, and provides both a vigorous defense of free-market capitalism and a powerful critique of capitalism’s relentless overturning of established ways.
    Since Berkowitz specifically calls out Harvard, and since I went there and no how to navigate its course catalogue, I thought I’d look into this.
    In the coming year, the Harvard Government (i.e., political science) department is offering exactly six courses on “Political Thought and Its History.” Two of the six courses (Gov 1060 “Ancient and Medieval Political Philosophy” and Gov 1061 “The History of Modern Political Philosophy”) are taught by Harvey Mansfield and so I trust the right won’t be slighted in his presentation. One is Eric Nelson’s Gov 1074 “Political Thought of the American Founding” which name checks John Adams in its three-sentence course description. There’s also Gov 1094 “The Jewish Political Tradition,” Gov 1092 “The Past and Future of the Left,” and finally Gov 1072 “Moral Issues in Contemporary Politics” which promises to “weigh both sides of arguments over such issues as economic redistribution, the rights of women and racial minorities, the political status of the family, the regulation of the beginning and end of life, and the conduct of foreign policy.” That doesn’t seem to me as if conservative thought is being ignored. Now you could fairly say that Harvard simply isn’t offering an especially large quantity of courses on the history of political thought in general but that’d be a very different complaint.
    Meanwhile, the course with the most students and the most direct policy relevance is the introductory economics course that was taught by economist and Republican Party operative Martin Feldstein in my day and is currently taught by economist and Republican Party operative Greg Mankiw.
    No doubt there is some college or university somewhere for which Berkowitz’s complaint is valid, but he specifically cited Harvard as an example and it doesn’t stand up to even cursory scrutiny. My initial impulse on reading his article was to crack a joke about how people don’t study conservative ideas because conservative ideas are of such low quality. I’ll restrain myself from saying that, but suffice it to say that the research methods and evidentiary standards being employed by Berkowitz and the WSJ op-ed page don’t exactly make a strong case for inculcating young people with the conservative approach.


    • Original article
    • Login or register to post comments

    Related

    • HARVARD VS. YALE: Which Is REALLY The Best Ivy League School?

      Harvard vs. Yale. The two universities regularly battle for the top spot on college rankings and claim some of the most powerful alumni networks in the world. But which school is really better?

    • The Future of Tenure and the Opportunities for Advancement in Science

      |Peter Boettke|I am very optimistic about the future of economic scholarship and economic education, especially for young people interested in the Austrian/market process tradition and Virginia School Political Economy.  The retirements that will come in the next decade will give individuals significant opportunity to compete for positions at universities and colleges throughout the US.

    • Will MOOCs Dilute Brands of Exclusive Colleges?

      The explosion of free, online courses from top-notch colleges such as Harvard, Wellesley and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology promises to revolutionize higher education.   The brightest professors and the most rigorous courses are no farther than a laptop away, open to all, with spiraling tuitions no longer an enormous barrier.   “We’re witnessing the end of higher education as we know it,” Northeastern University President Joseph Aoun predicted in a recent op-ed in the Boston Globe.  

    • But I told you _I_ am a historian of economic thought!

      |Peter Boettke|

    • Liberty for Whom?

      By James Kwak

    • Here Is What The Universities Of The Future Could Look Like

      We will see increasingly creative partnerships between for-profit entities and traditional universities, writes Linda Lorimer, Vice-President of Yale University.

    • The Colleges That Are Most Likely To Make You A Millionaire

      In news that will shock no-one, earning a Crimson pedigree may be the surest-fire way to amassing greenbacks.

    • UC-San Diego Voted Best College in America. Yale, Princeton Not Even in Top 30.

      UC-San Diego Voted Best College in America. Yale, Princeton Not Even in Top 30. You read right. The righteous redistributionists at the Washington Monthly have announced their annual ranking of colleges and universities. And University of California-San Diego (UCSD) came out on top, followed by UCLA, the University of California-Berkeley, Stanford, the University of California-Riverside, Harvard, Case Western Reserve, the University of California-Davis, Jackson State University, and the University of Michigan-Ann Arbor.

    • Partisan Grading: Democratic Professors Are More Likely to Redistribute Grades Than Republicans

      From a very interesting forthcoming paper in the American Economic Journal titled "Parti

    • Highed Education Bubble Update: A Public University Joins the Expanding $50k Club

    Latest

    ‘I don’t think the matter is going to go away’: Deputy mayor calls Rob Ford’s statement on crack allegations a ‘good first step’
    ‘I don’t think the matter is going to go away’:...
    New book is a fuddle-duddle-seeking missile aimed at shattering the enduring Trudeau myth
    New book is a fuddle-duddle-seeking missile aimed...

    User login

    • Create new account
    • Request new password
    • Click on the icon to sign in with your social network login or enter your Bullfax.com login

    Our Blog

    • Tata Steel, ECB, China’s car market and European Corporate Tax in Our News for Today 05/24/2013
    • Pandora: the charm might fade away
    • Japanese Market, Indian Rupee, China’s Stocks and Oil Prices in Our Daily Round-Up for 05/23/2013

    Markets Map

    Markets Map

    Follow Us

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS
    S&P 500: 1649.60 -0.06% FTSE: 6654.34 -0.64% Nikk.: 14612.45 0.88% DAX: 8305.32 -0.56% HSI: 22618.67 -0.23% FX: EUR/GBP: 1.1694 USD/EUR: 1.2935 JPY/USD: 101.175 Commodities: Gold: 1386.60

    Bullfax.com - Market News & Analysis 2008-2011
    Contact Us | About Us | Terms & Conditions

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS .

    Secondary menu

    • Latest News
    • Top Rated
    • Most Popular
    • Archive
    • Discussions