Jump to Navigation
Home

Main menu

  • Home
  • Latest Stories
  • Markets Map
  • Trends and Sentiments
  • Leading Topics
  • News Search
  • Comments and Analysis

Secondary menu

  • Latest News
  • Top Rated
  • Most Popular
  • Archive
  • About Us
  • Bullish Takeaways From Vericel's Analyst And...
  • Kimberly-Clark's (KMB) CEO Thomas Falk on Q1 2018...
  • Fox News host Sean Hannity took out $2.5 million in loans...
  • Why Amazon is obsessed with getting inside of our homes
  • OCC Hosts Detroit Workshop for Board Directors and Bank...
  • Richard Jenrette, 89, Wall St. Power and Preservationist...
  • Kate and William can afford 3 kids. Many Brits cannot
  • Billionaire CEO won't stop trying to save Toys...
  • Jeff Bezos once said he has Bernie Madoff to thank for hi...
  • A Closer Look At China Mobile's Q1 Results, Q2...

    Gotta Close the Bad Charter Schools

    Wed, 10/14/2009 - 08:31 EDT - Mathew Yglesias
    • Comments
    • Education
    • uncat

    Dana Goldstein’s final column for The American Prospect looks at some examples of murky evidence in the education policy realm. The point is well-taken, but I think in one specific example she uses—charter schools—the policy solution is pretty clear:
    In the past six months, two high-profile studies of charter schools, both out of Stanford University, have attracted significant media attention. The first, a study of charter schools in 16 states conducted by CREDO, an education research group affiliated with the university, found that in math, only 17 percent of charters increase achievement over traditional public schools. The report’s authors called the results “sobering.”
    The second, a close look at 75 New York City charter schools by education economist Caroline Hoxby, a Stanford professor and Hoover Institute fellow, couldn’t have drawn a more disparate conclusion. Hoxby’s study, comparing students who win charter school lotteries to those who lose them, found that New York charter students do 31 points better in math and 23 points better in English than their lottery-losing peers, who remain in neighborhood public schools.
    Whatever you think of the methodological dispute here (Goldstein explains it well and I guess I side with Hoxby) the crux of the matter is that there’s substantial variation in the performance of different charters. What you need to do is identify schools that consistently perform poorly and shut them down. Then you create space for more effective models to replicate themselves and also for new ideas to be tried out. The promise of charter schools is that by allowing more experimentation we’ll find some good models. But it’s not as if public education in the United States currently achieves some theoretical maximum of badness—with experimentation we’re also discovering bad models. You’ve got to shut those models down, while at the same time curbing state legislators’ tendency to impose arbitrary numerical caps on the total quantity of charter schools. We should let a thousand flowers bloom and then kill 20-30 percent of them if they turn out to look ugly.


    • Original article
    • Login to post comments
     

    Related

    • Just Give Up on the Bad Charter Schools

      Cardozo High School, Washington DC (cc photo by Mr. T in DC)

    • A new study raises a troubling question about charter schools

      A new paper from three Duke University researchers studied the North Carolina charter school movement and came to a disturbing conclusion.

    • Charter High Schools Increase Earnings and Educational Achievement

    • One type of charter school has an 'overwhelming negative impact' on students

      Charter schools — which are publicly funded but privately run — have proliferated across the US since they first emerged as an alternative to traditional public schools (TPS) in the early 1990s.

    • The results of a new Stanford University study could surprise charter school critics

    • Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos is endorsing online schools, but student scores may indicate a big problem

      Associated Press/Carolyn KasterIt was the best of times and the worst of times for virtual schools, which allow students to go to school without ever stepping into a school building.

    • Trump's education secretary is a big advocate for charter schools, but one particular type might pose a problem

      AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster, FileWhat President-elect Donald Trump and the Republican sweep of government will mean for K-12 education priorities over the next four years is not entirely clear yet. However, policy statements and administration selections so far indicate “school choice” will top the agenda.

    • A Despicable Way to Use Education

      On Thursday, July 25, dozens of bankers, hedge fund types and private equity investors gathered in New York to hear about the latest and greatest opportunities to collect a cut of your property taxes. Of course, the promotional material for the Capital Roundtable’s conference on “private equity investing in for-profit education companies” didn’t put it in such crass terms. But that’s what’s going on.

    • “Race to the Top” Funds Structured to Encourage States to Drop Restrictions on Performance Data

      Albuquerque High School (cc photo by cjc4454)

    • Cato Institute Threatens to Unleash Plague of Bizarro Schools on America

      Andrew Coulson tells us that Cato is putting together an event on replicating high-quality schools:

    Latest

    Kunstler: "America Has Become An Alzheimer Nation"
    Kunstler: "America Has Become An Alzheimer...
    Princess Charlotte upstaged both her brothers by giving crowds outside the hospital a regal wave
    Princess Charlotte upstaged both her brothers by...

    Markets Map

    Markets Map

    Follow Us

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS
    S&P 500: 2579.37 0.16% FTSE: 7487.96 -0.07% Nikk.: 22420.08 1.82% DAX: 13465.51 1.75% HSI: 28594.06 1.22% FX: EUR/GBP: 1.1401 USD/EUR: 1.1618 JPY/USD: 114.1510 Commodities: Gold: 1276.1000

    Bullfax.com - Market News & Analysis 2008-2011
    Contact Us | About Us | Terms & Conditions

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS .

    Secondary menu

    • Latest News
    • Top Rated
    • Most Popular
    • Archive
    • About Us