Jump to Navigation
Home

Main menu

  • Home
  • Latest Stories
  • Markets Map
  • Trends and Sentiments
  • Leading Topics
  • News Search
  • Comments and Analysis

Secondary menu

  • Latest News
  • Top Rated
  • Most Popular
  • Archive
  • About Us
  • Boeing beats profit estimates, margins rise
  • Competition to build the Navy's MQ-25 flying tanker...
  • Tesla-powered race series to debut
  • Waffle House shooting suspect erased data
  • Twitter is profitable again and adding users
  • GOP unsettled by narrow win in US House race in Arizona
  • WWE Greatest Royal Rumble 2018 To Showcase Oppression,...
  • NBA Playoffs 2018: April 25 Schedule, Bracket, TV...
  • How Technology Could Help Or Hurt Your Business
  • How Leading Brands Are Closing The Loop For Smarter In-...

    A World Without a China

    Thu, 12/09/2010 - 09:31 EDT - Mathew Yglesias
    • China
    • Comments
    • trade
    • uncat

    Americans have some odd ideas about the strength of the Chinese economy:
    IMG_0088
    In the poll, only one in five Americans said that the U.S. economy is the world’s strongest — nearly half picked China instead. Looking forward, Americans are somewhat more optimistic about regaining primacy, but still only about one in three expect the U.S. economy to be the world’s strongest in 20 years. Nearly three-fifths of those surveyed said that increasing competition from lower-paid workers around the world will keep living standards for average Americans from growing as fast as they did in the past. Ruben Owen, a retired Boeing engineer in Seattle who responded to the survey, spoke for many when he said, “We’re still in a reasonably good place … but it’s going to get harder because other places are growing stronger.”
    Note that China is not only poorer than the USA, it’s poorer than Ecuador. It’s about half as rich as Uruguay or Belarus. Trinidad has about triple the per capita GDP of China. I think it’s probably true that average living standards in America are no longer the highest in the world, but we’re being beat by the likes of Norway, Switzerland, and the Netherlands not by China. But who knows? Maybe “stronger” just means “growing really fast” in which case China is, in fact, growing really fast.
    The larger point is that, as Jamelle Bouie observes, “the world isn’t zero-sum, at least when it comes to the global economy.”
    Just think about the impact on the United States if, for no clear reason, everyone in China died tonight. Would that decline in low-wage competition boost American living standards? It’s difficult to see how. Lots of stuff Americans buy is made by Chinese people. If the Chinese people die, we won’t have that stuff. Maybe Americans could make it instead. But then whoever’s making that stuff would need to stop producing whatever it is they’re producing now and start making made-in-China stuff. Either way, it adds up to less stuff being produced. Less stuff = lower, not higher, living standards.
    But aha! you say. Currently we have about 9.8 percent of the population unemployed. They’re not producing anything. Absent China, maybe those people would be mobilized and we’d equalize the quantity of production. And there’s something to that. It does seem to be a shame that 9.8 percent of the people in America who want a job producing something are currently producing nothing. And, indeed, it is a shame. But it’s not the existence of China that’s got them in their current state of non-production. It’s poor macroeconomic policy in the United States. We have the ability right now to mobilize many unemployed people and have them do something. We just need to spend money to pay them to do something. Doesn’t “the money have to come from somewhere?” Not really. Money is just made up by the government. If we need more money, the government can create more money. What “has to come from somewhere” is actual productive capacity. But the existence of China doesn’t reduce our capacity to produce. On the contrary, it increases the world’s productive capacity. But America’s political leadership has failed to fully mobilize our productive capacity, leaving more and more people adrift and fantasizing about the notion that somehow doing away with “competition” from foreign producers is the best way to reduce idleness.
    The voters are confused about this, but the political leaders are the ones who fundamentally deserve the blame for the sorry current state of affairs.


    • Original article
    • Login to post comments
     

    Related

    • It’s Not The Dollar that’s Dead, It’s the USA!

      “When the going gets tough, the tough get going” is a wonderful piece of linguistic wizardry. It can be read in two different ways. Either the 'tough' become fully engaged in combat and fight it out till the bitter end or the ‘tough’ up sticks and move out. It was supposedly Joseph P. Kennedy (father of US President John F. Kennedy) that gets the praise for having said it first. Once upon a time, in a far off place called the United States of America where that became a historical byword to describe exactly how they did business, it was once the first meaning that always held true.

    • Americans prefer low prices to items that are 'Made in USA'

      http://syndication.ap.org/AP.Distro.ContentBroker2/ContentBroker.aspx?contentid=4fd2bdd906231013960f6a7067009d99&iid=ec73230f3c5b4614860663cc9ea05f4f&rsn=0&recordid=ec73230f3c5b4614860663cc9ea05f4f&filingId=9b0c5a4ed5fb4a459a4d26c79f0ad1f2&role=Preview&reldt=2016-04-14T16:29:15&media=Photo&sz=&dest=ak&trF=WX103&ofn=AP%2bPoll%2bMade%2bin%2bAmerica.JPE

    • Dear Americans: You Are All Rich

      I have made the point a number of times that the bottom 20th percentile (in term of income) of US families would actually be in the 80th percentile in many nations.  In fact, it turns out that the 20th percentile person in the US would not just be relatively rich in many other countries, but on a global scale sits around the 85th percentile of world income.  Virtually no one in the US would even be in the bottom half of world income. This chart from a recent study was shared by David Henderson:

    • Americans produce a lot of garbage

      The world dumps 11.2 billion pounds of trash every year, according to the United Nations Environment Programme. This leads to land-use issues, health problems through groundwater contamination, and global warming because of the release of methane gas. While more trash is a bad thing, it's a pretty reliable indicator of economic activity and standards of living.

    • China's Rising Imports of American Goods

      As Americans in the 1970s sang that they’d like to “teach the world to sing,” Coca-Cola was entering the Chinese market. More than 30 years later, China is the beverage company’s third largest market, and Coca-Cola is still seeing modest growth in China.

    • Americans Have the Cheapest Food in the World

      Inspired by an item in today's "The Gartman Letter," the chart below displays data from the USDA comparing household spending on food as a share of final consumption expenditures for 84 countries around the world.  Dennis Gartman comments:

    • The global economy isn't zero-sum

    • Is prison gerrymandering the new three-fifths compromise?

      By Jamelle Bouie The NAACP’s Legal Defense and Educational Fund excoriates prison-based gerrymandering in a new report:

    • Chinese Trade Numbers Come In Massively Below Forecasts

      China on Saturday reported a sharp slowdown in exports in May compared to the previous month while imports unexpectedly dropped, as the world's second largest economy grapples with slowing growth and sluggish overseas demand. Overseas shipments rose just one percent to $182.8 billion last month, far lower than 14.7 percent recorded in April, customs authorities said in a statement.

    • R&D Following Manufacturing to China

      I’ve been urged on any number of occasions to worry more loudly about the decline of manufacturing employment in America, so here’s a link to Ed Luce in the FT:

    Latest

    Germany's choice of what new fighter jet to buy may come down to which can carry nukes
    Germany's choice of what new fighter jet to...
    Twitter Soars As It Beats Across The Board... But Can It Hold
    Twitter Soars As It Beats Across The Board... But...

    Markets Map

    Markets Map

    Follow Us

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS
    S&P 500: 2579.37 0.16% FTSE: 7487.96 -0.07% Nikk.: 22420.08 1.82% DAX: 13465.51 1.75% HSI: 28594.06 1.22% FX: EUR/GBP: 1.1401 USD/EUR: 1.1618 JPY/USD: 114.1510 Commodities: Gold: 1276.1000

    Bullfax.com - Market News & Analysis 2008-2011
    Contact Us | About Us | Terms & Conditions

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS .

    Secondary menu

    • Latest News
    • Top Rated
    • Most Popular
    • Archive
    • About Us