Jump to Navigation
Home

Main menu

  • Home
  • News
  • Markets Map
  • Sentiments
  • Topics
  • Data
  • Comments
  • Images
  • Blog
  • About

Secondary menu

  • Latest News
  • Top Rated
  • Most Popular
  • Archive
  • Discussions
  • The 5 Things You Need To Know In Mobile
  • Nike Is Donating $1 Million In Apparel, Plus Profits From...
  • Durable Orders Bounce Back
  • US durable goods orders rise 3.3 percent in April
  • JELL-O Is Trying To Rebrand The Abbreviation 'FML...
  • U.S. Mobile Commerce Grows Nearly Three Times Faster Than...
  • NewsWatch: Bernanke dares you to buy stocks
  • The Five Biggest College Myths
  • Australian Housing Bubble Has Chinese Overtones
  • Recession Is Coming

    Waiting for Clarity on a Greek Bailout

    Wed, 02/10/2010 - 15:03 EDT - Megan McArdle
    • Comments

    As most of you already know, Greece is in big, big trouble.  Its deficits are enormous, its debts are larger, and its credit quality is so shaky that it may set a world record on the Richter Scale. For a while now, the consensus has been that larger, more solvent members of the eurozone would bail the country out. Greece's creditors are saying, in effect, "Nice eurozone you've got there . . . shame if anything happened to it." And it would be.  There's no real mechanism for a country to exit the eurozone.  That is, from all accounts, deliberate--a currency zone doesn't work if you start with the assumption that countries may exit at any time.  The problem is, if a country is forced to exit, the process is . . . well, let's just say it's disorderly.  If Greece leaves the currency union, the best case scenario is a local bank run and a sharp jump in interest rates for euro-denominated debt, particularly that issued by weaker members, as lenders start pricing in currency risk.  The worst case scenario is that Ireland, Spain, and Portugal also suffer bank runs, forcing them to exit as well, which fatally weakens the whole project.This is why almost everyone expects the richer members to eventually come through.  The problem is, there's also no mechanism for delivering a bailout.  Greece can't ask for one, because it thinks this would undermine the credibility of its plan to reduce the deficit.  (Note to Greece:  this is like Paris Hilton worrying that buying an Amy Tan novel might undermine her reputation for intellectual seriousness).  And Germany, the obvious candidate to lead a bailout, is not eager to do so.  So while everyone knows this is going to happen, no one is quite ready to say, "Hey, we're going to hand Greece a bunch of money and get little in return except, well, not having our currency zone broken."No one has the authority to do the obvious:  swoop in with a bunch of cash, in return for which the Greek government gets put on a serious diet.  I mean, they can tell Greece to get its fiscal house in order, and negotiations over this sort of thing are part of the reason for the delay.  But while they can force Greece to agree to austerity measures, they can't actually enforce them, other than with a set of fairly pitiful sanctions.  Which is why Greece is running such huge deficits in the first place, even though the rules of the monetary union say that deficits aren't supposed to exceed 3% of GDP.  Since it is entirely possible that Greece will find itself in the same pickle ten years hence, no one's exactly enthusiastic about making this sort of committment.  Giving Greece money also gives markets the idea that Greece is Too Big to Fail, which means that if Greece does end up in trouble again, a bailout will be even more necessary.  None of the choices are good.  Thus we wait until everyone, including the Germans, reluctantly concedes that there is no other way to get out of this than to funnel money into the eurozone's most profligate government.

    Email this Article
    Add to digg
    Add to Reddit
    Add to Twitter
    Add to del.icio.us
    Add to StumbleUpon
    Add to Facebook


    • Original article
    • Login or register to post comments
     

    Related

    • Time to target the ‘resourceful rich’ to pay for eurozone bailouts, German experts say

      Wealthy households would face new taxes on property and other assets under German plans to prop up the struggling eurozone. Senior advisers to Chancellor Angela Merkel are pushing for better-off households to pay towards the cost of any future bailouts for the weaker members of the single currency. The proposals, from members of Germany’s council of economic experts, raise the prospect of taxes being imposed on property in a country like Spain if its government was forced to seek a bail-out.

    • De-Euroizing Spain

      Corcoran310 tweets “I really think u should do what u can to get Spain to ditch the euro. a weak Spanish currency would be awesome, I love madrid.”

    • Germany Draws Up Plans for Greece to Leave Euro; Athens Rehearses the Nightmare of Default; Merkel's Denial Rings Hollow

      It's been crystal clear for weeks, if not much longer, that Germany has been actively seeking to persuade Greece to abandon the Euro. Confirmation came on February 7 with Merkel's Official Denial "I will have no part in forcing Greece out of the euro"; Schäuble Starts Salami Tactics on German Participation, Calls for Vote .

    • Greek Bailout, Lehman Deceit, And Tim Geithner

      By Simon Johnson We live in an age of unprecedented bailouts.  The Greek package of support from the eurozone this weekend marks a high tide for the principle that complete, unconditional, and fundamentally dangerous protection must be extended to creditors whenever something “big” gets into trouble.

    • An Unlikely Exit for the EMU?

      Marc Chandler submits:There has been more talk in recent days that a current member of Europe's Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) will look for an exit. Greece is serving as the lightening rod, with 10-year bond yields soaring 23 bp today, though many observers have referred to the risk as being in the PIIGS countries-- (Portugal, Italy, Ireland and Greece).Some of the market talk focuses on the near-term--this year.

    • Ireland Bailout Cheer Is Dangerously Premature. Here's How to Play Markets Accordingly

      Cliff Wachtel submits: Asian stock markets closed mostly higher, and thus far today European indices are printing unanimously and appropriately in the green in the opening hours, as are commodities and risk currencies ( by ‘risk’ currency forex, traders refer to a currency that usually rises with stocks and other risk assets, the label has no connection to their stability). The optimism is dangerously premature, primarily because the EU i

    • Is Spain Next?

      Today, we're fortunate to have Mark Copelovitch, Assistant Professor of Political Science and Public Affairs at the University of Wisconsin, as a Guest Contributor. First off, let me thank Menzie for the opportunity to "pinch hit" here at Econbrowser. It's a pleasure to be here.

    • The Eurozone Disaster Will Happen in Three Waves

      Rebecca Wilder submits:Greece is now “high yield”, “junk”, “below investment grade”, at least according to S&P. What I mean by that is S&P now rates Greece’s foreign and local currency sovereign debt at the BB+ level (with a negative outlook), below the sometimes-coveted investment grade status; BBB- is the minimum.

    • The Next Global Problem: Portugal

      By Peter Boone and Simon Johnson The bailout of Greece, while still not fully consummated, has brought an eerie calm in European financial markets.  It is, for sure, a massive bailout by historical standards.  With the planned addition of IMF money, the Greeks will receive 18% of their GDP in one year at preferential interest rates.  This equals 4,000 euros per person, and will be spent in roughly 11 months. 

    Latest

    The Economy May Be Able To Escape The Dreaded Economic 'Soft Patch'
    The Economy May Be Able To Escape The Dreaded...
    Here's What Apple Design Leader Jony Ive Is Telling People He's Doing To The iPhone's Software (AAPL)
    Here's What Apple Design Leader Jony Ive Is...

    User login

    • Create new account
    • Request new password
    • Click on the icon to sign in with your social network login or enter your Bullfax.com login

    Our Blog

    • Tata Steel, ECB, China’s car market and European Corporate Tax in Our News for Today 05/24/2013
    • Pandora: the charm might fade away
    • Japanese Market, Indian Rupee, China’s Stocks and Oil Prices in Our Daily Round-Up for 05/23/2013

    Markets Map

    Markets Map

    Follow Us

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS
    S&P 500: 1643.70 -0.41% FTSE: 6656.75 -0.6% Nikk.: 14612.45 0.88% DAX: 8292.19 -0.72% HSI: 22618.67 -0.23% FX: EUR/GBP: 1.1671 USD/EUR: 1.2936 JPY/USD: 101.175 Commodities: Gold: 1387.45

    Bullfax.com - Market News & Analysis 2008-2011
    Contact Us | About Us | Terms & Conditions

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS .

    Secondary menu

    • Latest News
    • Top Rated
    • Most Popular
    • Archive
    • Discussions