Jump to Navigation
Home

Main menu

  • Home
  • News
  • Markets Map
  • Sentiments
  • Topics
  • Data
  • Comments
  • Images
  • Blog
  • About

Secondary menu

  • Latest News
  • Top Rated
  • Most Popular
  • Archive
  • Discussions
  • Durable Orders Bounce Back
  • The 5 Things You Need To Know In Mobile
  • Nike Is Donating $1 Million In Apparel, Plus Profits From...
  • The Five Biggest College Myths
  • 5 Commodity Stocks Moving On News
  • Australian Housing Bubble Has Chinese Overtones
  • Recession Is Coming
  • US durable goods orders rise 3.3 percent in April
  • JELL-O Is Trying To Rebrand The Abbreviation 'FML...
  • U.S. Mobile Commerce Grows Nearly Three Times Faster Than...

    "Scroungers": what's the problem?

    Thu, 01/05/2012 - 10:31 EDT - Stumbling and Mumbling
    • Comments

    Ed Miliband and Liam Byrne want to get tough on “evil” benefit scroungers. This is not evidence-based policy making.
    Let’s look at the evidence, in the form of table 12g of the ONS’s survey of subjective well-being.
    This shows that the  unemployed are significantly less happy than those in work. In answer to the question “overall, how satisfied are you with your life nowadays?” the average unemployed person replied 6.3 on a 0-10 scale, whereas the average employed person replied 7.5.
    This is a big difference - equivalent to six standard errors. It means the unemployed are less happy than people who are divorced,  widowed or who have a longstanding illness or disability.
    The overwhelming majority of unemployed people, therefore, far from being content to scrounge, are pretty miserable. Any leftist party worth anything would have this as it basic premise.
    In this context, the possibility that some people don’t want to work should actually be welcomed by any utilitarian. The fact is that mass unemployment is probably here to stay. If a few people don’t want to work, therefore, this increases the chances of other unemployed people finding a job, and thus moving out of deep unhappiness.
    Let’s look at this another way. Let’s assume that a million “scroungers” were to move into work; this is an utterly incredible assumption, given that there are only 455,000 job vacancies, and given that there’s no evidence that there are so many scroungers. But bear with me. By how much would this raise GDP?
    If they were all to get full-time minimum wage jobs - earning £11,000 per year - aggregate labour income would rise by £11bn - less than 0.8% of GDP. Add in the fact that it’s profitable to employ them (ex hypothesi) and we’re talking a rise in GDP of around one per cent.
    But this is puny compared to loss in GDP caused by the financial crisis. Andrew Haldane at the Bank of England estimated (pdf) this to be 10%. And it’s looking unlikely that we’ll recoup this through faster growth any time soon. 
    The cost of “scroungers”, then, is an order of magnitude smaller than the cost of bankers.
    The evidence, then, suggests that “scroungers” are, at worst, a mild problem. So why expend political capital fretting about them? The nicest thing I can think of is that this is another example of how moralizing is displacing rational policy-making.

    • Original article
    • Login or register to post comments
     

    Related

    • Welfare benefits & unemployment

      Don Paskini claims that higher welfare benefits help people find work, pointing out that between 1996 and 2009, the numbers of lone parents in work increased, at the same time as benefits did.His commenters are right to say the evidence doesn’t prove his claim, because perhaps even more people would have found jobs if benefits had been lower. But the evidence does prove something - that higher benefits can be consistent with lower benefit claims.

    • Paul Krugman: Raise That Wage

      Raising the minimum wage is the right thing to do:

    • Unemployment, scarring & well-being

      Morrissey was right. When he sang “I was looking for a job and then I found a job and heaven knows I’m miserable now”, he was getting at an important point.

    • "Scroungers" and exploiters

      Ed Miliband raises a point that should be embarrassing for both Marxists and New Labour. He says:We promised fairness but people felt that their version of fairness was violated by the irresponsibility of others – whether amongst bankers or people who could work but didn’t.

    • Les misérables: Despite welfare state and wine, unhappiness reigns in France

      France has good wine, a great culture, a 35-hour work week and a miserable population. A study by the Paris School of Economics shows that despite having all the things needed for a good life, the French are among the unhappiest people on the planet. “It has now become common knowledge that the French are much less happy and optimistic than their standard of living would predict,” says The French Unhappiness Puzzle: The Cultural Dimension of Happiness by researcher Claudia Senik.

    • The Erosion Of The U.S. Economy In Two Words: Jobs And Wages

      Submitted by Charles Hugh Smith from Of Two Minds The Erosion Of The U.S. Economy In Two Words: Jobs And Wages The current de facto policy of inflating asset bubbles to spark a "wealth effect" is no substitute for policies that make it less burdensome to start new enterprises and hire employees.

    • Democrats Cannot Possibly Lose By Pushing To Raise The Minimum Wage

      The issue that seems to have gotten the most attention in Barack Obama’s State of the Union Address on Tuesday is his proposal to raise the minimum wage to $9 per hour from $7.25.

    • A minimum income, not wage, is a fairer way to distribute wealth

      This article appears in the April edition of the Financial Post Magazine. Visit the iTunes store to download the iPad edition of this month’s issue.

    • US Minimal Wage, Facebook, Vodafone and India In Our News for Today 02/18/2013

      President Obama claimed for increase in minimum wage to $9 per hour. Facebook won a lawsuit in Germany over users privacy rights. Vodafone will dismiss 620 employees in its Spanish department. India’s Current Account Deficits might reach $87.9 billion in 2012.  

    • Dutch Women and Part-Time Work

      I’d long known the factoid that Dutch people generally do the least work of anyone in the world:

    Latest

    15 Things I Wish I Knew As A First Year Investment Banking Analyst
    15 Things I Wish I Knew As A First Year...
    Congrats On Your New Award, Jony Ive! (AAPL)
    Here Are Some Of The Big Changes Coming To Your...

    User login

    • Create new account
    • Request new password
    • Click on the icon to sign in with your social network login or enter your Bullfax.com login

    Our Blog

    • Tata Steel, ECB, China’s car market and European Corporate Tax in Our News for Today 05/24/2013
    • Pandora: the charm might fade away
    • Japanese Market, Indian Rupee, China’s Stocks and Oil Prices in Our Daily Round-Up for 05/23/2013

    Markets Map

    Markets Map

    Follow Us

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS
    S&P 500: 1640.61 -0.6% FTSE: 6660.27 -0.55% Nikk.: 14612.45 0.88% DAX: 8306.09 -0.55% HSI: 22618.67 -0.23% FX: EUR/GBP: 1.1676 USD/EUR: 1.2942 JPY/USD: 101.015 Commodities: Gold: 1390.10

    Bullfax.com - Market News & Analysis 2008-2011
    Contact Us | About Us | Terms & Conditions

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS .

    Secondary menu

    • Latest News
    • Top Rated
    • Most Popular
    • Archive
    • Discussions