Jump to Navigation
Home

Main menu

  • Home
  • News
  • Markets Map
  • Sentiments
  • Topics
  • Data
  • Comments
  • Images
  • Blog
  • About

Secondary menu

  • Latest News
  • Top Rated
  • Most Popular
  • Archive
  • Discussions
  • 25/5/2013: Saturday Reading Links
  • Rebuilding rules as rain soaks Jersey shore
  • **L'Esprit de l'Escalier: May 25, 2013**
  • Photos: Dortmund vs. Bayern
  • 7 Signs Household Finances Are Getting Stronger
  • Huge Flooding In San Antonio Area
  • Women Account For Less Than 20% Of Movie Critics
  • Highway Bridge Collapses After Two Trains Collide In...
  • Why Don't More People Link to Felix Salmon and Ryan...
  • AirAsia sticks to year-end launch; to order more jets

    The Mechanics of Banking: Take 3

    Sun, 03/21/2010 - 03:04 EDT - Seeking Alpha
    • KBE
    • Kid Dynamite
    • KRE

    Kid Dynamite submits:
    Believe me - it's not that I really enjoy talking about the mundane theoretical mechanics of the banking system - it's just that it's driving me crazy. So I'll try to get my questions answered here. Let's put aside reserves for a second - for the purposes of the questions in this post, let's simplify and pretend that reserve requirements do not exist - they are zero. There are frequently repeated mantras from "those who understand." The first of these mantras is "banks don't need deposits to make loans." What I still haven't been able to get a good answer to, is, "If I open up the Bank of Kid Dynamite, how do I give my loan customers the money that I loan them if I don't have any deposits?" I still have to give them (the borrower) the money. So, does it come out of my equity - my startup capital? OR, do I borrow (the loan amount - not reserves, remember) it from the Fed, using my equity as collateral? [my guess would be that it comes out of my equity] In essence, the Fed would become a depositor at my bank? [my guess would be NO, but it seems like this is certainly possible at some point - WHEN is that point? I think the whole cycle is actually easier to understand if I DO borrow the money from the Fed, who lends to me based on my equity as collateral - I hope that's how it works!] If I find $100MM in the street and open up a bank, refusing to take in any customer deposits at first - how many loans can I make? $100MM? Some amount slightly less, like $90MM, due to regulatory capital requirements (NOT due to reserve requirements!)? [My guess would be $90MM, assuming RegCap requirements of 10%. But wait - maybe it's $1,000,000,000 - the Fed will lend me $1billion, and my $100MM would be collateral - RegCap requirements?]. Would I be borrowing any money from the Fed or the interbank market in this scenario? [my guess would be NO, but it's quite clear that I don't know the answer!] Expanding the question, what if I had $100MM in equity, and I also took in $100MM in deposits? How many loans can I make now, and would I be borrowing any money from the Fed/interbank market? [my guess would be that I can loan out the $100MM in deposits - remember, we have no reserve requirements - and I can also loan out $90MM of my equity capital - but I'm not super confident in that answer.] The second mantra is "loans create deposits." HOW? Someone please explain this to me. Look - I certainly understand the theory that if the Bank of Kid Dynamite lends $100k to MikeMortgage so that MM can buy a house, and MM takes that $100k and buys a house from HarryHomeseller, then HH will hopefully deposit that money in the bank. BUT - HH doesn't need to deposit that money at the Bank of Kid Dynamite - he might bring it to another bank. So, how does making loans at the Bank of Kid Dynamite create deposits at the Bank of Kid Dynamite? EDIT: I think I may have just had a "loans create deposits" epiphany: When the Bank of KD loans money to someone, like MikeMortgage, even if that money doesn't end up getting deposited back in my bank, it hopefully (theoretically) gets deposited SOMEWHERE, say Bank of Anonymous. Then, Bank of Anon lends it's excess deposits back to me, Bank of KD... right? Essentially, I get a deposit (aka: I borrow) from the Bank of Anon. In an effort to keep it simple, I'll leave it there...Complete Story »

    • Original article
    • Login or register to post comments
     

    Related

    • Bernanke warns shadow banking risks persist

      CHICAGO — U.S. Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke said on Friday that the shadow banking system still posed a threat to financial stability, and funding markets might still not be able to cope with a major default. In a wide-ranging speech explaining the Fed’s role in monitoring the health of the banking system, Bernanke also laid out how the central bank was looking at asset markets closely for signs of excessive risk taking.

    • Survey Evidence and Banking Reform

      Steven HorwitzOver at the Cobden Centre, Toby Baxendale reports on a study he commissioned, written by Anthony Evans and several co-authors, looking at what the public does and does not understand about how the banking system works.  (Full disclosure:  Tony showed me an early draft of the questions and I provided him some feedback on precise wording, but I was not compens

    • Guest Post: Say Goodbye To The Purchasing Power Of The Dollar

      Submitted by Adam Taggart of Peak Prosperity blog, On a long solo car trip last week, I listened to several podcasts to pass the time. One was a classic: The Invention of Money, originally released by NPR's Planet Money team back in January of 2011. I highly recommend listening (or re-listening) to it in full.

    • The microfoundations of banking

      MAINSTREAM macro models fail to represent some of the most basic realities of the financial system. One reason is that doing so is hard. Another is that for a long time it did not seem to make much difference. In the absence of crises, the activities of the financial sector can appear irrelevant for long stretches of time. Small wonder so many academics model the economy as if banks and other intermediaries simply do not exist. The crisis, which was completely unanticipated by the vast majority of academics and policymakers, revealed some of the drawbacks of these shortcuts.

    • Repoed, Part 3: Proof Deposits Are At Risk And A Disappearing Act Explained

      By Colin Lokey:In two previous articles (here and here) I suggested that banks use excess deposits and excess cash in general to make risky bets on a variety of securities including, but certainly not limited to, equities.

    • Slovenian Economist Emails "Our Banking System is on Brink of Collapse"; Housing Crash and Incompetent Bureaucrats Blamed

      In response to last Friday's post Slovenian Bond Yield Breaks 7%, First Time Since Euro Entry in 2007 I received an interesting email from a Slovenian economist who says "Our banking system is on the brink of collapse."Luka Gubo writes ...Hello Mish!

    • Contrary to Hank Greenberg, ETF Mechanics are NOT Beyond Comprehension

      Kid Dynamite submits: Herb Greenberg did a segment on CNBC yesterday about Bogan's "Can ETFs Collapse Piece." I used to read Greenberg 10 years ago when he was the voice of reason in finding overvalued internet stocks, and found him to be intelligent, informed, and useful. I guess times have changed.

    • Shadow Banking for Beginners

    Latest

    Where popularity never meets critical acclaim: Why bland entertainment is worth a fortune
    Where popularity never meets critical acclaim:...
    Huge Flooding In San Antonio Area
    Huge Flooding In San Antonio Area

    User login

    • Create new account
    • Request new password
    • Click on the icon to sign in with your social network login or enter your Bullfax.com login

    Our Blog

    • Tata Steel, ECB, China’s car market and European Corporate Tax in Our News for Today 05/24/2013
    • Pandora: the charm might fade away
    • Japanese Market, Indian Rupee, China’s Stocks and Oil Prices in Our Daily Round-Up for 05/23/2013

    Markets Map

    Markets Map

    Follow Us

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS
    S&P 500: 1649.60 -0.06% FTSE: 6654.34 -0.64% Nikk.: 14612.45 0.88% DAX: 8305.32 -0.56% HSI: 22618.67 -0.23% FX: EUR/GBP: 1.1694 USD/EUR: 1.2935 JPY/USD: 101.175 Commodities: Gold: 1386.60

    Bullfax.com - Market News & Analysis 2008-2011
    Contact Us | About Us | Terms & Conditions

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS .

    Secondary menu

    • Latest News
    • Top Rated
    • Most Popular
    • Archive
    • Discussions