Jump to Navigation
Home

Main menu

  • Home
  • News
  • Markets Map
  • Sentiments
  • Topics
  • Data
  • Comments
  • Images
  • Blog
  • About

Secondary menu

  • Latest News
  • Top Rated
  • Most Popular
  • Archive
  • Discussions
  • Here Are All The Billboard Music Awards Winners
  • Regulators Scrutinize Firms' Ties to Insurers
  • Oklahoma governor declares state of emergency after...
  • Staying afloat on inflation-indexed bonds
  • Analysis: At margins of shale oil boom, a tempered...
  • Is your car insurance cover big enough?
  • US consumer data brighten Asia’s mood
  • The Expert View: Babcock, Petrofac and Pearson
  • Analysis: At margins of shale oil boom, a tempered...
  • Asia markets up after US delivers positive data

    Ken Clarke & two politics

    Thu, 05/19/2011 - 09:52 EDT - Stumbling and Mumbling
    • Comments

    I’ve never understood why many people had a high regard for Ken Clarke. Even so, I fear the fuss about his remarks on rape reflect discredit not just upon him, but upon our political culture too.What I mean is that there is a genuine and tricky political question here that is being overlooked.Imagine we were to implement one implication of the “rape is rape” view and give all rapists long sentences. Because people are risk-seeking in the domain of losses, this would discourage guilty men from pleading guilty as they‘d prefer to take their chances with a trial. This would have two effects. It would inflict upon victims the trauma of giving evidence and reliving their ordeal. And - juries being juries and reasonable doubt being reasonable doubt - it would mean that some guilty men might get off.Clarke’s proposal to discount sentences for guilty pleas is intended to diminish these costs.What we have here are a set of trade-offs. There’s a trade-off between giving rapists long sentences on the one hand and ensuring all the guilty are convicted on the other. And there’s a trade-off between justice - insofar as harsh punishments are just - and minimizing costs, both to the victims in terms of giving evidence and to tax-payers in terms of banging people up for long spells.These trade-offs are ubiquitous in sentencing policy. In some cases, the sentences that are best from the point of view of deterring crime might be too harsh for the requirements of justice. In other cases the sentence necessary to ensure adequate punishment might actually lead to more recidivism. The various things we want from sentencing policy - justice, deterrence, rehabilitation and cost minimization - will in many cases conflict with each other.And herein lies the essence of what proper politics should be; a debate about what to do when values collide. Of course, judges must have discretion in individual cases, but their decisions must be taken within parameters set by informed public opinion about such values. But this is not the debate we’re having. Instead, we’re seeing three ugly aspects of our political culture. One is a tendency to view all political utterances through the prism of whether or not they are “gaffes” - the effect of which will be to discourage plain speaking, or indeed speaking at all. A second is an atavistic tribalism, which leads both Ed Miliband and The Sun to demand Clarke’s resignation, both on the grounds that he is not “one of us.”And this leads to a third aspect - the tendency for politics to be reported in terms of who's up/down/in/out - terms which are to a large extent uninteresting tittle-tattle. Meanwhile, the real substance of proper politics is forgotten. 

    • Original article
    • Login or register to post comments
     

    Related

    • Indian Gang Rape Victim Is 'Fighting For Her Life'

      NEW DELHI (AP) — The victim of a gang-rape in New Delhi fought for her life at a Singapore hospital Friday as officials in the Indian state of Punjab fired and suspended police officers accused of ignoring the rape of another woman, who then committed suicide.

    • Victim of hours-long New Delhi gang rape dies in Singapore hospital

      Doctors say a young Indian woman who was gang-raped and severely beaten on a bus in New Delhi has died at a hospital in Singapore. A statement by Singapore’s Mount Elizabeth hospital where the 23-year-old victim was being treated said she “died peacefully” early Saturday. The horrific ordeal of the woman galvanized Indians, who have held almost daily demonstrations to demand greater protection from sexual violence, from groping to rape, that impacts thousands of women every day, but which often goes unreported.

    • Victim of hours-long gang rape ‘fighting for her life’ in hospital as teen in second attack commits suicide

      NEW DELHI — The victim of a gang-rape in New Delhi fought for her life at a Singapore hospital Friday as officials in the Indian state of Punjab fired and suspended police officers accused of ignoring the rape of another woman, who then committed suicide. Indian authorities have been accused of belittling rape victims and refusing to file cases against their attackers, further deterring victims — already under societal pressure to keep the assaults quiet — from reporting the crimes.

    • The attackers ‘had such promising futures’: CNN’s Ohio rape case coverage sparks online firestorm

      As the public got news of the guilty verdict in the high-profile Steubenville, Ohio, rape case, CNN reporter Poppy Harlow commented how it was hard for her to watch. “It was incredibly emotional, incredibly difficult, even for an outsider like me, to watch what happened as these two young men that had such promising futures, star football players, very good students, literally watched as they believed their lives fell apart,” Harlow reported. It was the start of an online firestorm.

    • Feds unveil 2013 tough-on-crime agenda including tougher penalties for child sex offences

      If you thought the federal government was through its tough on crime agenda — think again. Justice Minister Rob Nicholson unveiled a plan Monday for 2013 that includes new legislation to toughen penalties for child sex offenses, create a Victims Bill of Rights and better protect the public from those found not criminally responsible due to a mental disorder.

    • Protesters demand death penalty for New Delhi gang-rape suspects as ‘thousands of rape cases’ languish in India’s courts

      Authorities shut down roads in the heart of India’s capital on Sunday to put an end to a week of demonstrations against the brutal gang-rape of a woman who died recently, and was cremated on Sunday. Thousands of armed police and paramilitary troops blocked roads in central New Delhi to prevent protesters from marching to the presidential palace. A small group of demonstrators gathered at a venue about a kilometer away from India’s parliament to press the government to ensure the security of women in the city.

    • This Stunning Graphic Reveals The Sad Outcome Of Most Rape Cases In America

      The Washington Post's Dylan Matthews posted “The saddest graph you’ll see today,” a graphic from the Enliven Project that provides a shocking overview of our legal system’s failure to identify and jail rapists:

    • Acquitted Conduct Sentencing

      This story was interesting.Suppose you are charged with a crime. There won't be just one item on the indictment. There will be 10-20 or more charges.The jury may reach a "compromise verdict". They will acquit you of the more serious charges, but vote guilty on a lesser charge.

    • Iran hangs four rapists, drug trafficker: report

      Iran has hanged four men convicted of rape and another man found guilty of drug trafficking in Tehran, government newspaper Iran reported on Wednesday.The men hanged on Tuesday were identified as Mehdi, 33, convicted of raping at least two teenage boys, an unnamed 21-year-old man who had raped a retarded 22-year-old woman two years ago, and two other unnamed men who had broken into a house late at night and raped a woman.

    • Conservative Justices’ Strange Enthusiasm for the Punishment of the Innocent

      John Roberts (Wikimedia)

    Latest

    Israel seeks interim peace deal, says Palestinians ‘still not psychologically ready for an agreement’
    Israel seeks interim peace deal, says...
    Here Are All The Billboard Music Awards Winners
    Here Are All The Billboard Music Awards Winners

    User login

    • Create new account
    • Request new password
    • Click on the icon to sign in with your social network login or enter your Bullfax.com login

    Our Blog

    • Aviva steps up drive for cost cuts
    • Food Demand, JM Financial, UK Startups Incubator and Sina in Our News for Today 05/17/2013
    • Budget black hole at heart of George Osborne’s finances

    Markets Map

    Markets Map

    Follow Us

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS
    S&P 500: 1667.47 1.02% FTSE: 6723.06 0.52% Nikk.: 15357.38 1.43% DAX: 8398.00 0.33% HSI: 23474.029 1.67% FX: EUR/GBP: 1.1831 USD/EUR: 1.2846 JPY/USD: 102.661 Commodities: Gold: 1344.05

    Bullfax.com - Market News & Analysis 2008-2011
    Contact Us | About Us | Terms & Conditions

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS .

    Secondary menu

    • Latest News
    • Top Rated
    • Most Popular
    • Archive
    • Discussions