Jump to Navigation
Home

Main menu

  • Home
  • News
  • Markets Map
  • Sentiments
  • Topics
  • Data
  • Comments
  • Images
  • Blog
  • About

Secondary menu

  • Latest News
  • Top Rated
  • Most Popular
  • Archive
  • Discussions
  • 3M Co Management Presents at the Electrical Products...
  • Sino Agro Foods Management Discusses Q1 2013 Results -...
  • BHP Billiton Could Be An Intriguing Income Investment
  • 20 Reasons It's Awesome Growing Up Gifted
  • Zimbabwe mining chamber criticizes minerals proposals
  • Greece’s big economic recovery – for investors
  • Ergen Bids for LightSquared Spectrum
  • Panel: Apple uses firms outside US to avoid taxes
  • Senate panel says Apple avoids billions in U.S. taxes
  • Panel: Apple uses firms outside US to avoid taxes

    Fact-free politics

    Sat, 09/22/2012 - 06:37 EDT - Stumbling and Mumbling
    • Comments

    Chris Skidmore, one of the authors of Britannia Unchained, says:

    People aren’t interested in looking at medians and graphs. We have a duty to try and broaden that message outside of the think tank zone.

    I don't know what to make of this. It could be that Skidmore is recommending that politicians use social science in the way Paul Krugman urges economists to use maths - you base your policy upon it, but then find a way of advocating the policy in more populist language.
    Sadly, though, it is not at all obvious that Britannia Unchained's authors are using this resonable approach. They seem instead to have skipped the science and evidence and gone straight to the populism.
    This suggests an unkinder interpretation - that Skidmore thinks formal science has no place in politics. What matters is what sells, not what's right. 
    The problem here is that there is no strong obstacle to this descent into post-modern politics. The anti-scientific culture of our mainstream media means they will not call politicians out on their abuse of facts, unless the abuser is not in their tribe - as Jonathan complained in noting the press's reaction to Britannia Unchained.
    But does this matter? In one sense, maybe not. Expert support and empirical evidence does not guarantee that a policy will be a success - though I suspect it improves the odds.
    Instead, what worries me is that this threatens to further corrode the standard of political discourse.Fact-free politics need not be the sole preserve of the right; some of my readers will have the name of Richard Murphy in their minds. And if we go down this road, we'll end up with one tribe thinking the poor are all scroungers and the other thinking our economic problem can be solved by a crackdown on tax dodging. And the two tribes will just be throwing insults at each other. And there's a few of us who think this would be dull.

    • Original article
    • Login or register to post comments
     

    Related

    • What Economists to Listen to? And Why?

      I really wish that Jonathan Portes had written this before I had to give my talk on economists as public intellectuals yesterday… Jonathan Portes:

    • Politics, science and ego

      Two different blog arguments remind us how rare it is to find an empirical, scientific attitude in political debate.Take first Dave Osler’s contrast between Jade Goody and my fellow Corpuscle Gail Trimble. He says that “basic family details alone would be sufficient for most of us to have no difficulty in predicting” their very different academic attainments. But his first commenter points out that many people from poor backgrounds are academic achievers.

    • Paul Krugman: Lust for Gold

      What explains "goldbuggism"?:

    • Krugman Issues a Counter-Challenge to Austrians

      |Peter Boettke|

    • Paul Krugman: Against the Ignorance Caucus--the Republican Party

      Paul Krugman:

    • Why politics fails

      Sean McHale says Ed Miliband should learn from Barcelona. In doing so, he draws attention to why politics is so flawed a discipline. Sean says that, in the Real Madrid game, Victor Valdes continued to play short balls out of goal despite the fact that doing so had gifted Madrid a goal early doors. He advises Miliband to similarly stick to one track rather than fumble around in the dark.

    • Calling All ECONOMISTS, Let's Answer a Serious Question

      |Peter Boettke|

    • A campaign for social science

      Listening to this (about 14 mins in) and this, the idea occurred to me that if I weren’t so lazy, I would set up a campaign for social science.

    • "Common mistakes made by economists"

      Ezra's post is worth reproducing (after the intro) in full: ...here’s a list of mistakes that I think economists and people who are heavily influenced by economists tend to make when they look at politics. I should preface this by saying I have, at one point or another, been guilty of literally everything on this list:

    • A quantitative assessment of the scientific consensus on anthropogenic climate change

      From the abstract to the paper: ...

    Latest

    23-Year-Old Phenom Gareth Bale Agrees To Stay With Tottenham Despite The Team's Mediocre Season
    23-Year-Old Phenom Gareth Bale Agrees To Stay...
    What Eating Lunch At Your Desk Every Day Does To Your Body
    What Eating Lunch At Your Desk Every Day Does To...

    User login

    • Create new account
    • Request new password
    • Click on the icon to sign in with your social network login or enter your Bullfax.com login

    Our Blog

    • Quantative Easing: Not on the long run
    • China’s Insurers, PC Shipments, Bird flu Consequences and French taxes in Our Daily Round-Up for 05/20/2013
    • Yahoo buys start-up Tumblr for $1bn

    Markets Map

    Markets Map

    Follow Us

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS
    S&P 500: 1666.29 -0.07% FTSE: 6755.63 1% Nikk.: 15360.81 1.45% DAX: 8455.83 0.68% HSI: 23493.029 1.75% FX: EUR/GBP: 1.1842 USD/EUR: 1.2884 JPY/USD: 102.24 Commodities: Gold: 1394.05

    Bullfax.com - Market News & Analysis 2008-2011
    Contact Us | About Us | Terms & Conditions

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS .

    Secondary menu

    • Latest News
    • Top Rated
    • Most Popular
    • Archive
    • Discussions