Jump to Navigation
Home

Main menu

  • Home
  • News
  • Markets Map
  • Sentiments
  • Topics
  • Data
  • Comments
  • Images
  • Blog
  • About

Secondary menu

  • Latest News
  • Top Rated
  • Most Popular
  • Archive
  • Discussions
  • Naxal attack: Sonia appreciates courage of leaders
  • Traditional Stock Analysis Will Not Work For Tesla Motors
  • Is Main Street Capital A Long-Term Buy?
  • Jet Airways may raise Rs 250 cr by 5% stake dilution
  • From Kimchi To Kiwi: 10 Bonds You've Never Heard Of
  • AT&T: 'Administrating' Revenue Growth
  • Mutual Funds sell shares worth Rs 11,000 cr in 2013
  • BOJ's Kuroda says pain from bond yield rise is...
  • Links for 05-26-2013
  • China Biotech In Review: Hisun-Pfizer, Merck-Simcere JVs...

    Close substitutes vs. perfect substitutes

    Sun, 07/25/2010 - 08:29 EDT - Marginal Revolution
    • Comments
    • Economics
    • Food and Drink

    For me, pluots and grapes are close substitutes, though not perfect substitutes.
    Let's say a house visitor brings a big bag of pluots as a gift.  That distorts my optimum pluot-grape ratio.  But I don't eat all the pluots at once, simply to restore the preferred ratio.  That would be an unbalanced meal.  Instead, I dig into the pluot bag at a higher rate than I would normally eat pluots.  Over a longer period of time the proper ratio is restored, pluot by pluot. 
    The closer pluots and grapes are as substitutes, the longer it takes for equilibrium restoration.  But the closeness of substitution is not always the major factor determining the speed of adjustment.  It may be just as important, or more important, how hungry I am, how much of a glutton I am, and how much I like pluots.  It also matters whether I am fearing a large shock, requiring a major pluot reserve, such as when a bevy of pluot-devouring guests might suddenly visit the house.  
    In any case, equilibrium restoration eventually comes.  Those pluots will clear my refrigerator, sooner or later.
    Apply a similar analysis to cash and T-Bills.  At low nominal interest rates they are close substitutes but not perfect substitutes.  T-Bills are of greater use for clearinghouse collateral, and yield a bit more, but they are not liquid in exactly the same ways.  Even if cash and T-Bills are close substitutes, monetary policy will change the banks' mix and so banks eventually will reequilibrate, converting extra cash into AD, one way or another.  But as with the pluot adjustment, this won't happen all at once.
    Equilibration (and the accompanying AD boost) may be slow, maybe too slow for comfort.  But the degree of substitutability is not the only factor determining the speed of this adjustment, just as with the pluots.   The degree of bank and business confidence may be the most important factor.  Other factors will be the cues from the Fed, the corporate cultures of the banks, possible uncertainty, transactional frictions (the difference in returns is small but perhaps the cost of adjusting is small too), and so on.  The degree of substitutability is one factor determining the speed of adjustment but not necessarily a major factor.  I am not sure it should be put in the top three most important factors.
    The zero bound argument assumes that the degree of substitutability is, at current margins, the major factor which matters.  You are being "sold" a model of portfolio adjustment with one dominant factor.
    Monetary policy is not working well today, but perhaps bank and business confidence is a bigger reason than the degree of substitutability.  From those who promote the relevance of the "zero bound" argument, you will see it implicitly assumed that we have a case of perfect substitutes and that substitutability is the major factor hindering portfolio adjustment, as would lead to an expansion of the broader money supply aggregates.
    In many models "close substitutes" and "perfect substitutes" have different very properties.  Current discussions of the liquidity trap usually neglect this point.
    Addendum: This is also a framework for thinking about ceasing to pay interest on reserves.

    • Original article
    • Login or register to post comments
     

    Related

    • Jordi Galí: Monetary Policy and Rational Asset Price Bubbles

      Another paper to read:

    • The market-perceived monetary policy rule

      Stanford Professor John Taylor has suggested that monetary policy could be summarized in terms of a simple rule, lowering interest rates when output is too low and raising them when inflation is too high. A number of academic papers have investigated this rule from the perspective of describing what the Federal Reserve has historically done.

    • Guest Post: More Monetary Quackery

      Submitted by Pater Tenebrarum of Acting Man blog,

    • The low rate conundrum

      LONGER-TERM interest rates have been low for quite some time now across much of the rich world, and there is little sign of an upturn any time soon. This is disconcerting. As Ben Bernanke put it in an interesting speech delivered Friday, there are two reasons to worry about low long-term rates: that they'll rise and that they won't. As rates remain low, financial market participants may be encouraged to "reach for yield", by taking dangerous risks and leveraging up.

    • How Negative Should Real Interest Rates Be?

      Antonio Fatas submits:Standard monetary policy is about setting short-term nominal interest rates. Most macroeconomic models assume that inflation is sticky (constant) in the short run and by moving nominal interest rate the central bank is actually setting the real interest rate and by doing so influencing spending (consumption and investment) decisions.

    • America: First time among equals

      It's not a fair fight, the currency war between the US and China - but it's more evenly matched than most us has ever seen. And as we saw in yesterday's sharp fall in the dollar, it has the potential to cause the rest of the world a lot of trouble. Whether in the economic arena or the political one - it's been a long time since the US could pick on someone its own size. When it comes to a currency war, China's peculiar economic system lets it come pretty close.

    • Modern Market Alchemy Explained: Converting Junk Debt Into Supersafe Treasurys Out Of Thin Air

      When it comes to the actual functioning of capital markets, there is always much confusion within the made for TV punditry for one simple reason: the number of people who truly understand collateral transformation courtesy of the shadow banking system, which until recently was a massive $23 trillion off the books repository of everything the banks did not want you to know about, can be counted on one hand.

    • Stagnation and Monetary Policy

      I strongly agree with Ryan Avent that monetary policy has likely played a larger role in generating some problematic long-term economic trends than people generally realize.

    Latest

    Credit spreads are moderately attractive
    Credit spreads are moderately attractive
    Mystery Surrounding Collapse Of Hong Kong Mercantile Exchange Deepens; Four Arrested
    Mystery Surrounding Collapse Of Hong Kong...

    User login

    • Create new account
    • Request new password
    • Click on the icon to sign in with your social network login or enter your Bullfax.com login

    Our Blog

    • Tata Steel, ECB, China’s car market and European Corporate Tax in Our News for Today 05/24/2013
    • Pandora: the charm might fade away
    • Japanese Market, Indian Rupee, China’s Stocks and Oil Prices in Our Daily Round-Up for 05/23/2013

    Markets Map

    Markets Map

    Follow Us

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS
    S&P 500: 1649.60 -0.06% FTSE: 6654.34 -0.64% Nikk.: 14612.45 0.88% DAX: 8305.32 -0.56% HSI: 22618.67 -0.23% FX: EUR/GBP: 1.1694 USD/EUR: 1.2935 JPY/USD: 101.175 Commodities: Gold: 1386.60

    Bullfax.com - Market News & Analysis 2008-2011
    Contact Us | About Us | Terms & Conditions

    Follow Us on Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and RSS LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS .

    Secondary menu

    • Latest News
    • Top Rated
    • Most Popular
    • Archive
    • Discussions